.png)
Among the most commonly used transfer methods in international payments are ACH transfers and wire transfers. The choice between ACH or wire transfer can affect the costs associated with a transaction, its processing time, and the security of payments
Generally, it is understood that ACH transfers are common with routine cost-effective transactions, specifically in the USA. On the other hand, the speed and reliability of large-value urgent transactions are achieved with wire transfers.
Let's dive into each of these methods in further depth and see which is best for your business transactions, ACH or wire transfer.
An ACH is an electronic system that allows money to be transferred between accounts from different bank institutions through a network. ACH is widely used and applied in the United States for direct deposits, electronic bill payments, and remittances from businesses to private individuals. The system is best suited for payment in batches, making the method ideal for recurring business-to-business or business-to-consumer payments, such as payroll and vendor expenses.
The ACH transfer process involves a network of clearinghouses that collect, collate, and then process batches of transactions at regularly scheduled intervals throughout the day. Here is a simplified view of how it works:
Although ACH transfers are safe, batch processing will make them take some days to settle, as it does not happen in real-time.
Low Cost: ACH transfers are inexpensive and incur very little fees, and they are excellent for business organizations with massive transaction volumes within the same country.
Regular Payments: It is a very useful process for regular, automatic payments such as payroll, recurrent supplier payments, or monthly invoices, making it easier to pay.
Control Over Recurring Transactions: ACH transfer enables businesses to arrange for recurring payments, thereby creating predictable cash flow and manual effort reduction.
Longer Processing Times: Compared to wire transfers, an ACH transfer is not instantaneous. For instance, while ACH entries are batched, several business days may go by until processing is fully done; hence it's not so great for timely payments.
Limited Availability for Cross-Border Payments: The ACH system mainly exists in the US. As such, when cross-border payments come into question, businesses often prefer other methods of transferring, since they might require the speed of a wire transfer.
ACH can be one of the best cost-cutting options available for the U.S. businesses if they need payment options that are efficient, frequent, and regular. Nevertheless, ACH may have a few restrictions for Indian businesses and other businesses that would need international capabilities, in terms of speed and globalization.
A wire transfer is an electronic method of transferring funds directly from one bank account to another. While ACH transfers process payment in batches, payments in wire transfers are normally done individually and in real-time. This method would allow for the immediate transfer of funds, making it an attractive option for businesses needing to send or receive money quickly. They could either be domestic or international transfers, and they mostly carry out these transfers across borders via network groups such as SWIFT.
A wire transfer progresses step by step for funds to be transferred accurately and with minimal risk:
The whole process is quite speedy, especially for internal transfers, while international wire transfers may take a little longer as it involves time zones and additional checks.
Speedy Processing: The wire transfer can be processed on the same day. It is suitable for urgent payments where the timing is critical.
Applicability in High-Value Transactions: Wire transfers are widely used in business transactions since the process is highly reliable and quick, especially when paying for inventory, paying contractors, or transferring money to other countries.
Higher Fees: They often carry a large transfer fee, especially when the receiver resides in another country.
Human Errors: Human errors in account numbers and bank details may delay some transactions or send money directly to the wrong account, so it is advisable that such information be checked carefully before submitting the transfer request.
Wire transfers offer a swift and reliable means of transferring funds, especially beneficial for urgent and high-value transactions. However, the associated costs and potential for human error mean that businesses must carefully consider when to use this method, particularly in the context of their financial strategies and operational needs.
Here’s a comparison table summarizing the differences between ACH transfers and wire transfers:
Both methods offer advantages and disadvantages for Indian businesses, particularly those that make repeated transactions with foreign countries.
In India, ACH transfers are difficult to find since it does not have a large physical presence and network reach. An ACH network mainly serves U.S. financial institutions and consequently could not be easily used in an intercountry transaction. However, businesses in India can use similar electronic transfer systems of National Electronic Funds Transfer (NEFT) and Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS), developed and operating similarly to ACH.
These systems allow Indian companies to clear routine, local disbursements such as salary cheques, vendor invoices, etc. However, NEFT and RTGS are only domestic instruments and don't facilitate direct international remittance.
Wire transfers are also available in India and can be done across the country. Indian companies can make and receive international wire transfers through the SWIFT network, which is very crucial in cross-border payments. For companies engaged in import/export or needing to pay international contractors, wire transfers are the primary option.
For businesses in India, cross-border payment options have evolved, providing alternatives that work alongside traditional ACH and wire transfers:
Foreign Currency Accounts: Indian companies can open foreign currency accounts with banks that enable holding, sending, and receiving funds in multiple currencies. This reduces conversion fees and supports faster payments.
Digital payment platforms: Companies like Karbon Business provide innovative solutions to send money internationally via virtual bank accounts. They offer a competitive exchange rate, faster transfers, and lower fees, especially for people with high international payment requirements.
Payment aggregators and FX services: Many businesses use services like PayPal, Wise, or specialized FX services while making cross-border payments.
In a nutshell, ACH is not directly accessible to Indian companies but several alternatives exist to ensure efficiency in both domestic as well as international transactions.
Karbon has resolved the choice between ACH vs wire transfer by giving businesses a virtual bank account in the U.S., through which receiving funds from another country is easy. It allows businesses to receive payments easily in U.S. dollars, and remit them to India for a fraction of the cost. Unlike payments via wire transfer, payments with Karbon involve no intermediary banks or fees because of our partnership with various US banks.
All this helps Indian businesses send and receive money internationally faster. As a specialized service designed for Indian businesses. Karbon also helps with documentation and compliance. If you’d like to know more about how we could help you, please contact us today!
Setting up ACH payments involves:
Overall, expect it to take around 3 to 10 days, depending on bank processes.
Yes, both ACH and wire transfers can be scheduled for future payments.
Yes, offering both options adds flexibility:
Specify in contracts or invoices to ensure everyone’s on the same page, with fees disclosed upfront.
Yes, but it is advisable to do it transparently, here’s how:
Always communicate clearly to avoid surprises and keep client relationships strong.
%20(1).png)
