Business

How Chargeback Fraud Is Hurting Indian Exporters and SaaS Companies

If you receive payments from international clients—whether through credit cards, PayPal, or Stripe—you’ve probably heard of chargebacks. It’s meant to protect buyers from fraud. But what happens when dishonest customers exploit that system?

That’s called chargeback fraud and it’s becoming one of the most annoying risks for Indian SaaS founders, digital marketers, consultants, and exporters.

In this article, we’ll break down what chargeback fraud is, why Indian companies are more vulnerable, and most importantly—how to protect yourself with safer international payment methods like SWIFT transfers.

What Is Chargeback Fraud?

Chargeback fraud—also known as friendly fraud—happens when a buyer tells their bank or card issuer that a charge was unauthorized, defective, or undelivered after they've already received the product or service. That may sound like a customer protection mechanism at first. But in reality, it's often a calculated—and very deliberate—abuse of that system.

There's a big difference between a legitimate dispute where a package never arrives or a subscription is billed incorrectly, and chargeback fraud. In those cases, the customer is genuinely upset. In chargeback fraud, the customer knows exactly what they're doing. They complete the purchase, wait for delivery or service to be fulfilled—and then falsely claim the charge was unauthorized. That way, they can get their money back without returning anything.

That's not an unusual occurrence. In fact, friendly fraud now accounts for 60 to 80 percent of all chargebacks in global e-commerce, according to industry reports. And because banks often side with the buyer, especially in cross-border cases, the business ends up carrying the burden of proof. That can be tough to fight, especially if you're selling digital goods or services.

For Indian exporters and SaaS companies selling abroad—especially to U.S. or European consumers—chargebacks can cause real problems. You might lose revenue, despite having fulfilled the order. You might get hit with penalties from payment processors like PayPal or Stripe. And you risk damaging your reputation and even having your account shut down.

Chargeback fraud is essentially theft by another name. And when your client is overseas, it becomes even harder to challenge those claims.

Join Us & Grow Your Business

Let’s explore opportunities, tailor strategies, and chart a course to financial success together.

Risks of Chargeback Fraud for Indian Businesses

Chargeback fraud is a global problem but Indian businesses face some unique systemic and structural challenges when dealing with international clients.

1. Currency Conversion Delays Can Hide Payment Disputes

International card payments go through multiple currency conversions and intermediary banks. These layers introduce delays and discrepancies that can make it hard for Indian businesses to detect a fraudulent transaction until it’s too late. By the time a chargeback is initiated, the service may have already been delivered.

2. No Local Representation in Buyer Markets

Having a local presence (like a US based office or legal entity) can help with buyer side verification, legal recourse, and faster dispute handling. Indian exporters without such representation are at a disadvantage both legally and perceptually when challenging a chargeback initiated by a foreign buyer.

3. Disproportionate Chargeback to Sale Ratio Penalties

Many payment processors (like PayPal) freeze merchant accounts or impose heavy penalties if the chargeback ratio crosses 1%, even if those chargebacks are fraudulent. For Indian SaaS businesses or exporters with lower transaction volumes, even 2 or 3 chargebacks can breach the threshold and lead to withheld funds or account termination.

4. Dispute Resolution

Mastercard’s chargeback process has multiple stages – pre-dispute, chargeback initiation, merchant response, decisioning, and arbitration. This can be overwhelming for Indian businesses, especially SME,s when dealing with international disputes. ​

5. Compliance

RBI’s Exchange Control Manual has strict compliance requirements for exporters – timely submission of export documents and specified payment methods. Non-compliance can attract penalties and impact future transaction capability.​

So, Indian businesses need to take measures against chargeback fraud like using secure payment channels and maintaining transaction records meticulously.

How Chargeback Fraud Works

Chargeback fraud is not complicated—it’s ridiculously simple. A seemingly legit customer places an international order or subscribes to a service and then reverses the payment later through their card issuer. Here’s how it plays out for Indian businesses selling globally:

Step-by-Step Breakdown

  1. Customer Makes a Payment
    The international client pays using a credit or debit card via Stripe, PayPal, or Razorpay. The funds are processed and credited to the Indian business’s account after currency conversion and intermediary processing.

  1. Service or Product is Delivered
    The business ships the goods or activates a service (like access to software, digital files). In most cases, especially for digital services, there’s no physical delivery confirmation.

  1. Buyer Files a Chargeback
    Days or even weeks later, the customer contacts their issuing bank and disputes the transaction. Reasons may include “unauthorized use”, “product not received”, or vague descriptions like “didn’t recognize the charge”.

  1. Bank Investigates—and Often Refunds the Customer
    In cross-border transactions, issuing banks often side with the buyer, especially if there’s not enough evidence. The bank reverses the charge and pulls the money from the merchant’s account.

  1. Indian Business Loses Both Money and Product
    By the time the business is notified, it’s too late. Not only is the money lost but so is the product or time invested. The merchant also gets chargeback fees and possibly higher fraud risk scores with payment gateways.

Chargeback fraud often hides behind legit-looking complaints. Without real-time alerts or strong documentation, Indian exporters and SaaS businesses can be easy targets. That’s why using secure, trackable payment rails like SWIFT transfers via virtual bank accounts is highly recommended.

How to Prevent Chargeback Fraud 

Chargeback fraud can be tough to reverse but it’s possible to prevent. Indian businesses dealing with international clients can reduce their risk by being more documentative, using better payment infrastructure, and being proactive about client screening. Here’s how to get started:

Use Service Agreements and Contracts

Sounds obvious but you should always formalize your engagements with clear contracts (even if you are a freelancer). These should have:

  • Payment terms and refund policy
  • Scope of work or deliverables
  • Client responsibilities and deadlines
  • Jurisdiction for legal disputes (important for cross-border work)

A signed contract—even digitally—adds a lot of weight to your case if a dispute arises, especially if escalated to a payment processor or bank.

Collect Proof of Delivery or Performance

For digital services or consulting, “delivery” isn’t always tangible, but it can still be verified. Keep:

  • Email chains confirming task completion
  • Shared drive timestamps or signed-off deliverables
  • Screenshots or Zoom recordings of live work sessions
  • User login records (for SaaS)

This kind of documentation strengthens your chargeback rebuttal file and proves the service was used or delivered.

Vet Clients Before Onboarding

Prevention starts before the invoice. Be cautious of:

  • First-time clients placing large orders
  • Incomplete business information (no website, no LinkedIn)
  • Requests for quick turnarounds + upfront work
  • Clients who resist signing basic documentation

For international clients, especially in high-risk regions, a basic due diligence check (e.g., business registry lookup, VAT verification) can go a long way.

Use Invoicing Tools With Clear Terms

Choose invoicing platforms that let you embed terms of service and refund policies into the invoice. This helps:

  • Make your policies clear and legally documented
  • Provide traceability for when payment was requested and made
  • Automatically generate audit trails that support your case

It also improves cash flow visibility and makes clients less likely to dispute impulsively.

Avoid High-Risk Payment Methods for Large International Deals

While credit cards and wallets are convenient, they’re also easiest to reverse via chargeback. For high-value international projects, consider safer alternatives like:

These methods don’t allow chargebacks in the same way cards do, giving Indian businesses more certainty and legal clarity.

Why SWIFT Transfers Are Safer

When dealing with international clients, one of the best ways to protect your business from chargeback fraud is by using SWIFT transfers. Unlike card payments, these transfers move money directly between verified bank accounts through a globally recognized messaging system—the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT).

Here’s why Indian exporters and service providers are increasingly switching to SWIFT for secure cross-border transactions:

Payments Are Irreversible

Once a SWIFT payment is initiated and settled, it cannot be reversed without the sender’s explicit consent. This eliminates the risk of buyers disputing a charge after receiving your product or service.

Higher Verification Standards

To make a SWIFT payment, your client must initiate the transfer through their regulated financial institution, which often includes multi-factor authentication, identity verification, and internal compliance checks. This reduces the risk of fraud compared to credit cards or wallets, where identity verification can be weak.

Best for High-Value and Recurring Transactions

For larger invoices—common in software licensing, consulting or bulk product orders—SWIFT is ideal. Many Indian B2B businesses using card payments face limits or high fees on larger amounts. SWIFT scales well for payments worth thousands of dollars or more, making it a preferred method for long-term or enterprise clients.

Reduced Intermediary Risks with Virtual Bank Accounts

When combined with international virtual accounts offered by fintech platforms like Karbon, SWIFT transfers become even more efficient. You can receive payments in USD, EUR, GBP, etc., and convert them to INR at competitive rates without funds getting stuck in intermediary bank loops that slow down traditional exports.

Transparent, Auditable and RBI-Compliant

Each SWIFT transfer generates a unique MT103 document, which acts as a digital proof of payment. This is not only useful for reconciling invoices but also helps with RBI export documentation such as FIRA (Foreign Inward Remittance Advice). It keeps your compliance clean and audit-ready.

SWIFT Transfers vs. Card Payments: What’s Safer for International Business?

Feature SWIFT Transfers Card Payments
Reversibility ✅ Irreversible once settled ❌ Can be reversed via chargebacks
Risk of Chargeback Fraud 🔒 Very low – no chargeback process ⚠️ High – fraudsters exploit chargeback loopholes
Best Use Case Large invoices, B2B deals, SaaS, exports Small-value purchases, B2C, trials
Compliance with RBI (India) ✅ Aligned with FIRA, MT103, and export rules ❌ Often lacks valid export documentation
Transaction Fees Moderate (flat + forex margin) High (2%–4.5% + FX markup)
Currency Support 100+ currencies via global banks Limited to gateway/card support
Processing Time 1–3 business days Instant to 48 hrs (but chargeback window remains)
Dispute Resolution Bank-led, based on legal contracts Buyer-biased (issuer often favors customer)
Fraud Screening Strong bank-level KYC/AML checks Basic checks, easily bypassed
Receivables Transparency Full audit trail (MT103, confirmation) Often unclear, esp. via aggregators

How Karbon Forex Can Help Prevent Chargeback Fraud?

Karbon is a smarter alternative to card payments for Indian exporters, agencies, SaaS companies and freelancers. With Karbon:

  • You can get paid via bank wires (SWIFT), not cards – no chargebacks.

  • Your clients pay into local bank accounts in the US, UK, or EU, and you get paid in INR back home, with full FIRA-compliant documentation.

  • Every transaction comes with MT103 proof and end-to-end tracking so your cash flow is auditable and secure.

  • Karbon’s system has built-in KYC checks and compliance layers to ensure every payment is legit and safe.

  • Reduce foreign exchange markups and fees compared to card processors who charge 3-4.5% per transaction to <1% charged by Karbon.

  • Karbon gives you auto-reporting and downloadable transaction records for compliance filings.

Whether you’re billing US clients for development services or collecting retainers from Europe, Karbon lets you do it the professional way.

Join Us & Grow Your Business

Let’s explore opportunities, tailor strategies, and chart a course to financial success together.

FAQs

Is chargeback fraud illegal?

Yes. Chargeback fraud, when a buyer intentionally disputes a legitimate transaction to reclaim funds, is a form of digital financial fraud. While the process is often handled by card networks, knowingly abusing it can be criminal intent and financial misrepresentation.

What are the legal consequences of chargeback fraud in India?

In India, knowingly committing chargeback fraud can lead to serious consequences under Information Technology Act, 2000 and Indian Penal Code (IPC). Offenders can be charged with cheating (Section 420 IPC), identity misuse and cybercrime. Penalties can include fines and imprisonment if the fraud involves forged documents or cross-border deceit. Businesses can also sue for damages or file a complaint with Cyber Crime Cell of Indian Police.

Can chargeback fraud be reported to authorities internationally?

Yes, especially if the transaction value is high. Merchants can report fraudulent chargebacks to Interpol’s cybercrime division and local cyber cells. But enforcement varies by jurisdiction and volume.

Is Stripe or PayPal safer for international payments than SWIFT?

For smaller transactions, Stripe or PayPal may be convenient. But they’re riskier for high-value B2B payments, especially for Indian exporters, due to higher fees, delayed settlements and higher chargebacks compared to irreversible SWIFT transfers.

Do clients hesitate to pay via SWIFT?

Not typically, especially in established B2B relationships. Many businesses globally prefer SWIFT for its audit trail and contractual clarity. Through Karbon, clients pay into local accounts, which removes friction and speeds up processing.

How fast are SWIFT payments through Karbon’s virtual accounts?

In most cases, funds are received within 1–3 business days. Karbon routes payments through local receiving accounts in the US, UK or EU, much faster than traditional cross-border wires.

The views expressed in the blogs on this page are solely the opinions of the authors and do not constitute expert advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the website for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. We disclaim any liability for any loss or damage including without limitation, indirect or consequential loss or damage, or any loss or damage whatsoever arising from loss of data or profits arising out of, or in connection with, the use of this website.

Similar posts

Discover Related Reads

Accept Global Payments in 30+ Currencies

Reach out to us today!
Get Started
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.